Collective Breath — our online Sangha — is a container for connection.
Each week, we meet on Tuesdays at 7pm to practice together. When you subscribe, you gain access to weekly gatherings as well as a library of talks, pre-recorded workshops, and discussions exploring Buddhist meditation and Qigong.
Following our recent exploration of the first foundation of mindfulness - the body and reclaiming the senses - today we turn to the second foundation of mindfulness: feeling. From Pali vedanā, is often translated in English as “feeling tone.” In psychology, this is sometimes called the hedonic tone of experience.
Vedanā is the immediate, subjective quality of what we experience and is felt within our body as sensations or feelings. We are talking about a subjective kind of knowing. Vedanā is a tone or quality of the things as we know them and we experience them as pleasant, unpleasant, or neutral. It’s the raw felt tone of experience before any interpretation.
We often notice vedanā most clearly in the body—through sensations like warmth, coolness, pressure, tension, softness. Although feeling tone also arises with thoughts and emotions, bodily sensations are the easiest doorway.
Every moment of experience contains one of the three tones:
Pleasant — anything from subtly agreeable to intensely joyful.
Unpleasant — from mild discomfort to sharp pain.
Neutral — neither pleasant nor unpleasant, often overlooked.
Just like with the gate I mentioned last week, if you can station yourself at the gate and watch everything that comes in, you decide who to let in. Everything that enters our world—sounds, sensations, thoughts, memories—passes through this gate and becomes known as pleasant, unpleasant, or neutral. If we can take our seat at the gate, we begin to see clearly what enters, how it feels, and whether it is nourishing and wholesome, unpleasant and unwholesome, or neither.
Without mindfulness, our responses are usually automatic
Pleasant → grasping, leaning in, wanting more.
Unpleasant → pushing away, tightening, resisting.
Neutral → drifting into dullness or inattention.
These reactions happen so quickly that we often don’t see the difference between the feeling tone and our response to it. “This is pleasant” becomes “I want that.” “This is unpleasant” becomes “I don’t want this.” When they fuse, we lose our freedom.
Let me share a small moment when this became clear to me.
